The Broken Arrow Cafe

Tucked away at 113 E Main St, Mahaffey, PA 15757, The Broken Arrow Cafe is a cozy beacon of homemade American goodness that feels like a warm embrace from the heart of the community. This local haven, dubbed The Broken Arrow Cafe Mahaffey, dishes out breakfast, brunch, lunch, and weekend dinners with a charm that’s hard to resist. Peek at The Broken Arrow Cafe Menu for a flavor preview, or dive into The Broken Arrow Cafe Mahaffey PA for the full story. At 10:48 AM +07 on Saturday, July 05, 2025, it’s the perfect time to fuel up—let’s explore this gem!

The Broken Arrow Cafe Mahaffey PA serves up comfort food that’s straight from the soul. I dropped in on a Saturday morning, greeted by the aroma of hot coffee and golden scrambled eggs, and dove into a creamy loaded baked-potato soup that warmed me to the core. The Philly cheesesteak hoagie, stromboli, and fried fish specials had locals raving, while Diane’s homemade pies—served by the slice—were a sweet finale. Yelp cheers the “big portions” and fair prices, with freshness shining in every bite, thanks to local sourcing that boosts Mahaffey’s economy.

The vibe here is pure community love—families and neighbors chat over wings and Reubens, making it a hub where locals frequently choose to gather. MapQuest nails it with “inviting ambiance,” and I felt it in the cozy booths and friendly staff who treated me like family. My server’s tip to try the fried-fish special, a local favorite, was spot-on, turning my visit into a memory.

This place shines with expertise—homemade ingredients, expertly crafted dishes like chicken tenders and breaded mushrooms, and consistent health standards (City-Data, January 4, 2024) build trust. The diverse menu, from soups to pizza, keeps it lively, with generous portions at budget-friendly rates earning nods from Yelp and MenuPix.

Swing by The Broken Arrow Cafe at 113 E Main St—open Tue-Sun (6 AM-7 PM, extended Fri/Sat)—or call (814) 277-7007. With its warm hospitality and hearty flavors, this Mahaffey treasure is a must-visit—go savor the charm today!